This movie is far more than anti-war. (by wanglivalley) |
Many people said it is an anti-war movie,I don't think so. This movie is far more than anti-war.Because it is not a rich story ,but a rich truth and an emotion. It doesn't want to give you an opinion about what war is, but show you an emotion about a young man and a war. A so-called hero came back from Iraq, how is his life?In the real world, the truth and emotion are complicated. So it is hard to say what its theme is. Maybe the theme is to doubt our fake society Maybe the theme is to show the hero's confused life. However, they are parts of this movie. It is more like a section <more> |
Effective and insightful anti war movie (by phd_travel) |
This is a very effective anti war movie. And it achieves a lot with a pretty low body count. It looks at a young soldier who after performing a heroic action caught on camera is involved in a promotional tour. It's subtle but completely clear in it's message.Through flashbacks there are many effective contrasts here between what went on in Iraq in attacks and the public relations football match slash Destiny's Child concert. Also showing the troops rounding up men in their home with their families watching.It is very insightful how he was about to give up the soldier life for this <more> |
Best line in the film (by darmstrong562) |
-Warning! Spoilers! Do NOT read this until AFTER you have watched the film.-Around 1:35 in the film, when Albert Chris Tucker is in the bathroom talking to Lynn about what "they call in my business, a Hollywood Moment."As he is reassuring him, he says that he will, "Go all the way to China to get this film made if he has to."So meta. So awesome. Even the cinematography there, with the pep talk to Lynn "..more Americans need to see the war like you guys do.." was straight out of a prior generation American propaganda flick. Vocal tone. Framing.Ang Lee and the <more> |
Not Actually A War Movie (by ssunzhong) |
This will be short and to the point. Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk is not a "war movie". It is not a propaganda picture about American Imperialism, it is not a recruitment poster, and it is most certainly not an action movie. War, in all its complexity, is incidental to this film. Billy Lynn just happens to be a soldier and the events that kick off the film happened at war. This is a film about labels.From the moment Billy is labeled a "hero" by the press for doing something he didn't have time to think about, his life is consumed. He comes a symbol to everyone <more> |
Make You Think (by barefootstallion) |
These young men come home to be celebrated, but instead find themselves dropped headfirst into America's worst examples of decadence and greed. It is the most accurate representation I've seen yet, of the cancer eating away at our great country.Bravo to Mr. Lee!I have to admit I wasn't expecting a great deal out of this movie's director, what with the failure of 'Hulk', but I walked away from it with a new depth of understanding. It was an astoundingly well portrayed film.I gave the movie 9 out of 10 because of Vin Diesel's lack-luster performance. Else, the movie <more> |
Quiet But Powerful (by destinylives52) |
Director Ang Lee has a knack for packing a serious, emotional punch in even the most quiet moments of a movie; and he does that again with "Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk," a mostly quiet movie that contemplates the craziness of war: started by the rich; fought by the poor and young; the physical and emotional damage it does to the soldiers and their families; the lies that are told to keep the war effort going; the lip service that most civilians give to the soldiers as life goes on as if there is no war happening, etc.After his heroic actions during the second Iraqi war are <more> |
Really Shows The Emotional Side of Being A Soldier (by bobhelms) |
A very well done movie that does a great job putting the viewer into the battle zone, even if you have never been there. If you have been there, you'll find yourself at times on the edge of your seat, holding your breath, a good dose of realism, the type of movie I would not have been able to go to for a couple years myself. A little iffy on some of the casting, and got a little far fetched 3/4 of the way through the movie with some of the relationship issues, so I give it an 8 out of 10.Liberals from NYC won't get this movie, because they have never been there. They refuse to have <more> |
stunning portrayal of post-war time (by patil_umesh) |
This is yet another tremendous work by Ang Lee. Movie showcases post- victory celebration of war heroes, opinions and responses of people in the nation, inability of people to perceive their sacrifice of personal life and struggle between life and death. The psychological state of nineteen year old young war hero is sketched very effectively. Innocence, teenage infatuation, parting, and vanity of war are well communicated through dialogues and expressions. Director has nicely showcased high end display technology used in current day's sports and media. Script juggles between war scenes <more> |
Soldiers are people too (by wynnlee) |
First of all, this movie is not about action but emotional feeling towards our heroes, "soldiers". Are they really hero?This movie show us how different people think of the soldier, like family's view, business man's view, public's view and worker's view. Who's the one that really appreciate what the soldier did for their country.This movie want us to see, how the soldier feel after they came back from war. All the cut-scenes are like face-to-face conversation, making you, the audience become part of the story. And of course, this movie is giving us a space to <more> |